This was a very interesting story, once I got the sense of what was happening in the story. The best part of the story for me was when the peasant was trying to bargain with the American Rug Collector. Near the beginning of the story, the American implies that peasants or other poor people who have a very valuable rug do not understand the value of the rug. A non-valuable scrap of carpet can be viewed as a piece worth from 1 dollar to several thousand dollars. The American feels he is much more intelligent than the peasants from the Middle East.
The American tells his tour guide, the man who feels he is disgraced, that he sees a similar trend with poor villagers in foreign countries; the villagers try to fake rare and ancient items and sell them. For example, a peasant might break one of their own vases, bury it, dig it up, and pretend it's an ancient item while trying to sell it for a profitable amount of money. While the American Rug Collector finds the peasants mischievous, I thought, in the section of the reading where they were in the archaeological dig, that the villagers were crafty because they created artificial artifacts, where some of the artifacts were handcrafted (they could've just sold the fake artifacts as themselves, but probably the tourists would be more interested in ancient artifacts).
When the American met the donkey seller, he found his true match for competing/ bargaining for a valuable rug. The American sees a priceless rug on top of a donkey's back and figures he must have it. At the beginning of the conversation between the donkey seller, the American, and the Turkish tour guide, the peasant seemed against the idea that the villagers are selling all of their household items and giving away Turkish treasures to foreigners. In turn at the end of the story, the donkey seller undermines his own statement. He appears to be confuzed at why the American wants to buy his old, male, mangy donkey. The American tries to hide the fact that he wants to have the rug otherwise, as he as seen in many cases, the villager will try to sell the rug at a higher price than can be bargained. When the peasants sells the donkey, he takes the antique rug off of the donkey's back and walks away, knowing that the American wants the rug. After a while, the villager comes back to the men and the American assumes that he is coming back to give him the rug. Instead, the peasant taunts the American by only giving him a stake for stationing the donkey. The American and the Turkish tour guide are surprised by the new behavior of the villager. The peasant confirmed that he knew the American wanted the rug, not the donkey, by saying, "If you are goin to let that donkey loose, please don't take him a far ways off, so you won't wear yourselves out."
After all, I think that Americans or other high class people are ignorant and can be tricked out of their own statements. They can't always assume that peasants aren't intelligent and that the high class can't always bargain for a cheap price while they sell it for more. Also, I finally understood why the Turkish tour guide kept repeating, "I'm disgraced." He was part in the negotiation between the American and the donkey seller. He let the American buy a donkey stake for two thousand five hundred liras. In a way, it was a good thing that the Turkish tour guide persisted on buying the donkey for the American who needed to learn his lesson. What goes around comes around.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
YOU SPELLED CONFUZED WRONG ION THE 3RD PARAGRAPH! ITS SUPPOSED TO BE CONFUSED!
ReplyDeleteI disagree with you. Its not stated explicitly that the owner of the donkey/rug knows that the American wants the rug! The man might just be naive. How do you know that he knew what the American was trying to do? PROOVE IT!
You didn't consider all the possibilities. You said the peasant confirmed that he knew the American wanted the rug, not the donkey, by saying, "If you are goin to let that donkey loose, please don't take him a far ways off, so you won't wear yourselves out." But what if he didn't know what the American was trying to do, but by his face could see that he didn't want the donkey but something else but didn't know what the something else was? I hope you understand that.. I know its complicated.
I disagree with you. I do not think that the donkey seller knew that the American wanted the rug. I think that he just thought that there was something very special about the donkey that he just didn't understand. Therefore, he sold it for an outrageously high price, but the expensive rug didn't come with it. He never figured out that the American wanted the rug, which is probably why he didn't know why the rug brought him luck selling donkeys. He didn't understand that the rug was very precious and that many rug specialists though that he was dumb so they try to buy the donkey with the rug.
ReplyDeleteIts very confusing, but in other words, the American thinks that the donkey seller is dumb so he tries to buy the donkey with the rug, but the donkey seller believes that the rug gives him success in a magical way. The only way it gives him success is that tourists like the American are trying to buy the rug with a donkey to trick the peasant, but the seller doesn't understand this and he thinks that it is just luck.